Nov. 18, 2026

A Payee Paid You Back. Do You Need to Correct the 1099?

A Payee Paid You Back. Do You Need to Correct the 1099?
Information Return Intelligence
A Payee Paid You Back. Do You Need to Correct the 1099?

What happens when you issue a Form 1099 to a contractor or vendor, and that person later pays back some of the money? Do you need to go back and correct the original 1099?

The answer depends on when the repayment happens.

In this episode of Information Return Intelligence, Jason Dinesen explains the difference between repayments made in the same calendar year and those made in a subsequent year—and why that distinction matters for Form 1099 reporting.

We also examine the recent Tax Court case Smith v. Commissioner. Although the case didn't directly involve Form 1099 reporting, it reinforces an important tax principle: each tax year stands on its own, and events in a later year don't necessarily change what happened in an earlier year.

It's a practical discussion of a common 1099 reporting question, with an important reminder about when corrections are—and aren't—necessary.

Information Return Intelligence is sponsored by the Institute of Finance and Management (IOFM) and produced by Dinesen Media Ventures.

SPEAKER_00

This week on Information Return Intelligence, we answer a common question that comes up about repayment of amounts that were reported on a 1099. Do you have to go back and correct the original? And there was a court case earlier this year that helps reinforce the concepts that are in play here. And that's what we'll talk about today on Information Return Intelligence, sponsored every week by IOFM. My name is Jason Dynason. Before we get started, our quick disclaimer this is not tax advice. Don't make any final decisions based on anything you hear in this podcast. Always pay appropriate counsel before making final decisions. Our topic this week is about a common situation that comes up. You have paid an amount that's reportable on a ten ninety-nine, and you do report it on a ten ninety nine, and then sometime down the road, your payee pays you back. What do you have to do in that situation? So just as an example, let's say that you pay your contractor $5,000 right now in 2026, and you properly report that on a 1099 NEC showing $5,000. Now fast forward a little bit to 2027, and for some reason they pay back $1,000 to you. Maybe they discovered that they overbilled you or whatever the reason is, they're giving you a refund of $1,000. Do you need to correct your 2026 1099? No, that's the short answer. As always, there's a long answer, so let's get into the long answer. With that scenario of making a payment to someone for a 1099able transaction, such as contract labor, and then they refund something back to you. If it happens in the same year, then you reduce the 1099able amount in that year. So when we say in that year, it means the same calendar year. So you pay your contractor $5,000 right now, and then before the end of the year, before the end of 2026, they refund $1,000 to you. You will reflect that on the $1099 for 2026 by reducing the amount on the $1099 by $1,000. So you made a $5,000 payment and now you've gotten $1,000 back and it happened all in the same calendar year, your $1099 will show $4,000 instead of $5,000. But the scenario that gets asked about more often is when you cross years. So you pay $5,000 now and report it on a 1099, and then sometime in 2027, your vendor pays $1,000 back to you. And the answer there is you don't do anything. You don't have to correct your 2026-1099 or change anything at all on 2026. Sometimes that kind of blows people's minds. There is a great court case earlier this year called Smith vs. Commissioner that helps reinforce this. This was not a 1099 case, but it gives us a great lesson into the 1099 implications and why you don't go back and correct the prior year 1099. We'll talk about that case next, but first a word from our sponsor, IOFM. The Institute of Finance and Management has certified over 25,000 financial operations professionals worldwide through its four certification programs. These programs include accredited payable specialist or manager, both US and Canadian specific versions available, accredited receivable specialist or manager, certified professional controller, and certified payment reporting specialist. That's the 1099 certification that I teach. These globally recognized certifications are available in English, simple Chinese, and Spanish. Learn more at IOFM.com. And now back to the show. This court case was called Smith vs. Commissioner. And it wasn't a 1099 case, but like I said before the break, it gives us a nice window into why you don't correct the 1099s that you might have issued. So Smith was this guy who had applied for Social Security disability benefits, and he got awarded benefits by the Social Security Administration in 2022. But he also continued to work while getting his disability benefits. So SSA had a problem with that. And in 2023 they said, hey, wait a minute, you gotta pay us back. So he did. There were $26,000 worth of benefits that he had received in 2022 that he ended up paying back. And he did pay them back over the course of 2023 and 2024. Social Security disability benefits for tax purposes are treated the same way as regular Social Security benefits, so they are potentially partially taxable. But on his 2022 tax return, Mr. Smith didn't report any of his disability benefits. And his logic was that he had to pay it back, and he did pay it back, so it wasn't really income, so he shouldn't have to report it. And the IRS said we disagree with that. You should have claimed this as income on your 2022 return. The case went to tax court, and the tax court sided with the IRS. And here's the reasoning in the court, and this helps us understand this 1099 issue where you've paid something in a particular calendar year and you've reported it on a 1099, and then in a future calendar year something gets paid back to you. This is why you don't change the 1099 that you issued. Tax filings, including your personal tax return or a business tax return, it's like a record of that calendar year, and it's a self-contained unit of what happened that year. And so the tax court said in 2022, which was the year in question, Mr. Smith had in fact received Social Security disability benefits. It wasn't an erroneous payment where SSA sent him something by accident. He had applied to SSA. And they determined he was entitled to disability benefits. Now later they said, you know what? You really weren't entitled to disability benefits, so you've got to pay it back. But that was in a future year. For 2022, this was his income. And Mr. Smith tried to argue that this was more like a loan because he had to pay it back, but the tax court said that's not how tax law works. This wasn't a loan. It was income and it was yours in 2022. The fact that you had to repay it, it doesn't affect the story that the 2022 tax return tells. Now, without getting us sidetracked on things that don't affect 1099s, Mr. Smith isn't not necessarily totally out of luck. There's this thing called a claim of right repayment, where if in one year you've claimed something as income and then in a future year you had to pay it back, you might get a deduction or a tax credit in the year of that repayment. But that would be down the road when he actually made the repayment. And at any rate, that's not your business anyway. Put yourself in SSA's shoes. You would have issued a $1099 in 2022. The fact that he had to pay it back in 2023 and 2024 doesn't affect the 1099 that you issued in 2022. And what happens on his tax return as far as deductions or credits for the repayment, that's his business on his tax return in those years. It's not your problem. The bottom line for you is you don't change your 1099 when you cross years on these things. Payment is made in one calendar year, repayment comes in a future calendar year. That doesn't affect the 1099 that you issued for that prior calendar year. That'll do it for this week's episode of Information Return Intelligence, powered as always by IOFM and produced by Dinason Media Ventures. Thanks so much for joining us, and we will talk to you again next week. Dynason Media Ventures.