Nov. 3, 2026

A Backup Withholding Discussion with Debra R. Richardson

This week on Information Return Intelligence, we talk with Debra R. Richardson, an AP expert with decades of experience in the field.

Our topic is backup withholding – something I often call the forgotten person in the 1099 world.

Sometimes, informally, we say things like "99.9% of the time." Well, that is literal when we talk about backup withholding – 99.9% of the time, it doesn't get done when it's supposed to.

The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) studied this issue in 2021. Their study looked at 2018. In that year, TIGTA determined that $14 billion of backup withholding should have been done – that's billion with a "B." According to the study, only $9 million – that's million with an "M" – got done.

That is a shocking figure. It comes to 0.06% of the backup withholding that should have been done actually getting done. Put another way, 99.94% of the time, backup withholding isn't getting done when it's supposed to.

It's not safe to assume that no one gets caught, because they do get caught. One example is a guy named James Quezada, who we will talk about in more detail in another post sometime. Quezada was a sole proprietor who failed to include SSNs on over 100 1099s he filed over a four-year period, and he didn't do backup withholding. The IRS assessed more than $1.2 million against him.

When you don't do backup withholding when you're supposed to, and the IRS comes calling, they're not going to chase after your vendors. They'll just assess the backup withholding that should have been done against your organization.

Luckily for Quezada, an appeals court ruled the statute of limitations had expired, so he ended up not having to pay anything to the IRS. But it's still a cautionary tale.

Debra and I break down backup withholding and vendor management in this episode of Information Return Intelligence.

Related Episode

52
Nov. 3, 2026

Backup Withholding: No W-9, No Pay? With Debra R. Richardson

Backup withholding is one of the most overlooked requirements in the Form 1099 world. What happens when a vendor refuses to provide a W-9? Can you simply refuse to pay them? And what happens if your organization fails to withhold taxes when required? In this special crossover episode, Jason Dinesen welcomes Debra R. Richardson, host of Putting the AP in Happy, for a practical discussion about backup withholding from both the tax compliance and accounts payable perspectives. Jason and Debra dis...